Author: Amanda Randle

AQMesh co-location comparison trial in Colorado, USA

During the months of October 2015 through to February 2016, two AQMesh pods were co-located against reference in Boulder, Colorado (USA), focusing on NO, NO2, O3 and CO measurement.

The trial resulted in impressively high correlation between AQMesh units and reference equipment, in some cases delivering R2 values higher than 0.98 (NO) and 0.87 (NO2).

Results of the trial have now been published in this full in-depth report, available to view or download as PDF.

Example NO results from the trial
AQMesh used in Transport Scotland’s Collaborative Sensor Rotation Programme

AQMesh-Laptop-mockup-300x200Transport Scotland recently piloted the installation of low cost air quality sensors at several locations near the trunk road network.

AQMesh pods were deployed at these various roadside locations to monitor the levels of pollutants. At the same time, traffic data was collected to allow comparison between traffic volume, speed and classification.

Analysing the traffic data indicated good correlation in certain circumstances, with lower speeds coinciding with higher readings in some pollutants. When cross-referenced with AQMesh data, it was found that the air pollutants linked with the most harmful traffic emissions are NO2 and PM2.5.

The full findings of the Collaborative Sensor Rotation Programme (CSRP) are available on the Transport Scotland website.

AQMesh scaled against reference demonstrates accuracy in new location – Barcelona, Spain

Through partnership with IDAEA-CSIC two AQMesh pods were co-located with a reference station and scaled locally in Barcelona (ref. Advanced user mode), providing R2 of 0.97 for NO and 0.89 for NO2. One pod was then moved to a second reference point within the city to establish repeatability of results using the scaling factors derived from the first reference. This resulted in a correlation of 0.98 for NO, and 0.86 for NO2. This trial shows that a high degree of air quality monitoring accuracy can be achieved through local scaling and this accuracy is maintained when AQMesh is then used to monitor independently in new locations.

AQMesh performance demonstrated in new co-location comparison trials

aqmesh_4AQMesh performance has been developed and refined through a series of global co-location comparison trials, with the results now available in the AQMesh website’s new performance section.

By co-locating AQMesh pods next to an air quality monitoring reference station and carrying out analysis, R2 values can be identified. R2 values range between 0.0 and 1.0, with the highest value indicating a perfect relationship between the data. Recent co-location trials delivered consistently high R2 values, proving a close match in readings from the pods and reference station.

New trials have been completed in a variety of locations with differing environmental factors, including Sweden, London (UK), Germany and Scotland.

Browse all trials for all parameters here.

AQMesh / ref co-location comparison results from Leicester (UK)

Urban background co-location (AQMesh and reference) of a single AQMesh pod gives R2 of  0.95 for NO and 0.81 for NO2 after local scaling (ref. Advanced user mode). Based on 4 weeks of data in the UK in January 2015. The next stage in this University of Leicester project is to co-locate all their 11 AQMesh pods with the reference station to calculate and apply scaling to achieve a high level of accuracy along with the already high performance between pods as well as against the reference station. The individual pods will them be moved out across the city of Leicester for a number of traffic monitoring studies, including a multi-point round-a-bout study looking at the differences in traffic pollution at the various stages of the process as well as other interesting applications for AQMesh…

View example data or return to the AQMesh performance blog page

AQMesh tracks pollution hot-spots

Read the case study.

Situated in the south west of Wales (UK), in a largely rural area bordering the Brecon Beacons, Carmarthenshire’s air quality is predominantly good. However, there are areas of concern where major roads pass through some of the County’s larger towns, including Llanelli, Carmarthen and Llandeilo, where air quality is dominated by the effects of road traffic. The County Council is therefore testing new monitoring technologies so that it will be better able to track the effects of improvement measures.

AQ-Mesh-Set-up-Castle-HotelCarmarthenshire County Council operates a network of passive diffusion tubes as part of its commitment to Local Air Quality Management under Part IV of the Environment Act 1995. However, in 2013, Air Monitors supplied the Council with a new type of air quality monitor, ‘AQMesh’, that is able to provide continuous air quality readings for a range of important parameters. This new technology is small, wireless, lightweight and battery powered, which means that it can be quickly and simply mounted in almost any location.

The Council’s monitoring programme has identified Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) from traffic emissions, mostly diesel vehicles, as the pollutant of greatest concern. A number of locations in the centre of Llandeilo have been shown to be in breach of European air quality standards, so an Air Quality Management Area (AQMA) has been established in the town. Whilst NO2 levels are not sufficiently high to cause immediate health effects, the current levels could cause adverse health effects over the long term, particularly in people suffering from respiratory conditions such as asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

NO2 reduction by about 25µg/m3 is the main objective of the air quality action plan, but the Council is determined to ensure that all pollutants remain at safe levels, so the ability of the AQMesh to monitor a wide range of parameters (Ozone, Carbon Monoxide, Sulphur Dioxide, Nitrogen Monoxide, Nitrogen Dioxide, Temperature, Humidity and Atmospheric Pressure) is a major benefit.

Stephen Hoskin from Air Monitors says: “There are a number of important new features in AQMesh that are fundamentally changing the way that air quality is monitored; firstly, it can be located where air quality matters most – where people are breathing.

“Secondly, in comparison with large reference stations, with only a small drop in levels of accuracy, the cost of monitoring is reduced dramatically, which means that users will be able to measure air quality in more locations, and this will reduce the UK’s current dependence on modelling to ‘guesstimate’ air quality.
“Finally, by providing near real-time data over the internet, useful air quality data can be made available to a much wider audience via smartphones, tablets and computers.”
AQMesh in Carmarthenshire is being operated by Oliver Matthews, one of the Council’s Environmental Health Practitioners with specific responsibility for air quality. He says: “In the past we have not continuously monitored this range of parameters because doing so would have involved the installation of a large, expensive air quality monitoring station that would have probably required planning permission.

“These reference stations offer high levels of accuracy, but come with large capital and operational costs, and cannot typically be moved, whereas the AQMesh can be quickly attached to a lamp post or other item of street furniture at a fraction of the cost.

“Alternatively, we could install passive diffusion tubes, one for each parameter of interest, but the disadvantage of this method is that the tubes are left in place for four to five weeks, so we are only provided with an average figure over that time, with no indication of the peaks and troughs that occur. For example, a recent road closure resulted in the diversion of traffic and, with the benefit of AQMesh, we were able to track a significant short-term rise in NO2.”

With the assistance of key stakeholders, the AQMA draft action plan has identified a number of options to improve air quality, and the AQMesh unit has been installed in order to help assess the success or failure of each initiative.

Interestingly, the development of the AQMA action plan benefitted from essential gas main works that were required in Llandeilo because this involved the closure of the main trunk road (Rhosmaen Street) for a period of up to three months, which provided an opportunity to identify the effects of traffic diversions on air quality.
Options that are being considered as part of the action plan include improving traffic management and seek to prevent vehicular ‘stop/start’ and promote a smooth flow of traffic. Typically, these options could include the provision of extra parking outside of the AQMA, the removal of some on-road parking within the AQMA, better parking enforcement, relocation of bus stops, reviewing pedestrian crossings and improvement of bottle necks.

Summarising Oliver says: “The network of diffusion tubes has enabled us to identify hotspots, and these are the locations at which the AQMesh will be of greatest use because we will be able to study trends and look for the causes of elevated pollution levels at specific times of the day.

“Data from the AQMesh are provided on a website via the ‘Cloud’ so, looking forward, this technology has the potential to make a major difference to air quality improvements and to the transparency and availability of data. For example, it may become possible to integrate air quality monitoring with automatic traffic management.”

Read the case study.
These AQMesh pods were supplied and supported by Air Monitors

AQMesh on Channel 4’s Dispatches – Dirty Secrets: What’s Really In Our Air?

At 8pm on Monday 22nd February, Channel 4 Dispatches revealed that air pollution could be much more dangerous than previously believed. The Dirty Secrets: What’s Really In Our Air? programme features AQMesh pods being used in tests to prove high levels of nitrogen dioxide (NO2) at road traffic hot spots – and even from your gas cooker – which could be a contributing factor for breathing problems and medical conditions, particularly in children, across the nation.

Read the full article by Channel 4

Watch the 30 minute programme, available for the next 29 days.

AQMesh partner Cambridge University releases low cost AQ sensors video and article

“Stable enough to be installed as long-term static detectors around a city, and sensitive enough to detect small changes in air quality on a street-by-street basis” says Professor Rod Jones of the University of Cambridge. See what else he has to say about the vision and development behind AQMesh here.

AQMesh / ref co-location comparison results from Germany

Heavy traffic site in a North German city. Co-location of two AQMesh pods with reference gives R2 of 0.96 for NO and 0.74 for NO2 after local scaling (ref. Advanced user mode) and pod to pod R2 of >0.97 for both NO & NO2. Based on 10 days of data from Germany in February 2015. Data courtesy of our German distributor Envilyse. The trial is still ongoing and an update will be sent out soon…

Example data can be found here.